Vesting on founder shares
Founders often issue themselves fully paid, fully owned shares on day one, on
the theory that they are the founders and the shares are obviously theirs.
The problem surfaces when one founder leaves after eight months holding the
same equity as a founder who stayed for five years. A reverse vesting clause,
under which founder shares are subject to buy-back or forfeiture on a vesting
schedule if the founder departs early, is the single clause that prevents this.
A typical structure is a four-year schedule with a one-year cliff, mirrored on
what investors will expect for the option pool later.
Good leaver, bad leaver
Not every departure is the same. A founder who leaves for health reasons or
by mutual agreement is usually treated as a good leaver, entitled to keep
vested equity and sometimes a portion of unvested equity. A founder who leaves
to join a competitor, or is removed for cause, is usually a bad leaver, with
harsher repurchase terms. Without this distinction written down in advance,
every departure becomes a negotiation conducted under stress, generally
through lawyers, sometimes through the courts.
Decision rights and deadlock
Two co-founders with equal shareholding and equal board seats is a common
starting point and a common source of paralysis. The founders’ agreement
should set out which decisions need unanimous consent, which need a simple
majority, and what happens if the founders cannot agree, whether that is a
casting vote, a cooling-off period, or a buy-sell mechanism. This is worth
resolving on paper while the founders are still on good terms.
Intellectual property assignment
Code, brand names, and product designs created by a founder or an early
contractor before the company existed do not automatically belong to the
company. Each founder and each early hire should sign an assignment agreement
transferring intellectual property created for the business to the company.
Investors check this specifically during due diligence, and gaps here are a
common reason a term sheet stalls. Fixing a missing assignment retroactively
is possible but slower, and it becomes harder the longer a founder has since
left the company on unclear terms.
- Get the founders’ agreement signed before the company opens its first bank account, not after the first disagreement.